Neighbours on the ferry route and favourites of the backpacker trail — but one revolves around dive tanks and the other around beaches, moon parties and yoga mats.
Find a room before you go.
Koh Tao runs on the dive-boat clock: early starts, two tanks before lunch, logbooks and cold drinks at sunset. Nearly everything on the island — the schools, the bars, the conversation — orbits around what is under the water. It is small enough to learn by heart in a day.
Koh Phangan runs on a looser clock. It is several times bigger, with proper distances between its beaches, a famous party corner at Haad Rin, and a west coast that has become a genuine wellness hub. You could spend a week here and have three entirely different holidays depending on where you sleep.
Affiliate link. If you book through it we earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
If diving or snorkelling is the point of your trip, Tao is the obvious base: cheap courses, sites minutes offshore, and shallow protected bays like Shark Bay and the John Suwan side where beginners can practise in calm water. Snorkellers see turtles and reef sharks without ever strapping on a tank.
The trade-off is variety. Beaches are few and small, nightlife is one friendly strip at Sairee, and non-divers can feel the island's single-mindedness after a few days. Most people come for a course, love it, and move on.

Phangan simply has more: more sand (Thong Nai Pan, Haad Yao, Bottle Beach), more nightlife (from the Full Moon Party to low-key beach bars), more yoga and retreats, more restaurants, and more room to spread out. Couples, long-stayers and digital nomads tend to settle here rather than on Tao.
Its diving is decent too — Sail Rock, one of the Gulf's best sites, is actually closer to Phangan than to Tao — but the school scene is smaller and the island's heart is on land. If you want one week of beaches with a two-dive day thrown in, Phangan covers it.

Easily — ferries link them in about an hour or so, several times a day. A classic route is a dive course on Koh Tao followed by beach days on Phangan.
Koh Phangan, without much argument. Koh Tao's bays are pretty but small; Phangan has long, varied beaches on every coast.
Phangan for scale — the Full Moon Party and the bar scene around Haad Rin and Ban Tai. Koh Tao's Sairee strip is fun but winds down early because everyone dives at dawn.
For a couple of days, yes — snorkelling, viewpoints and the Nang Yuan sandbar are excellent. For a longer stay, most non-divers are happier on Phangan.
More guides for this stretch of the Gulf coast.